WEST CHESTER (February 26) – State Senator Andy Dinniman will soon introduce two bills to address and help deter pet-shooting incidents like that which occurred on Feb. 12 in West Vincent where a family’s two dogs were killed by another neighborhood resident.

 

This month Senator Dinniman will introduce legislation amending the Pennsylvania Dog Law to better clarify the section that explains when one may shoot a dog on their property. Under Dinniman’s bill, such action would be allowed not when the dog is simply “pursuing” another animal but actually doing so “with apparent intent to harm.”

 

Argus and Fiona, the two Bernese mountain dogs that escaped from a neighbor’s yard were shot to death by a property-ownered in West Vincent.

Argus and Fiona, the two Bernese mountain dogs that escaped from a family’s yard and were shot to death by a neighboring property-owner in West Vincent.

Dinniman said this bill will apply within counties of the first, second and third classes. He said Chester County and the other more populated areas are where such conflicts are more likely to occur and where clarifying legislation is needed “so farmers and homeowners can better live in harmony.”

 

Senator Dinniman will introduce his other bill on Friday. It would let pet-owners seek civil damages for the injury or death of their dog or cat if the harm was inflicted intentionally or through negligence.

 

While Pennsylvania law currently allows pet-owners in such situations to recover their economic loss – specifically the price paid for the pet – Dinniman’s bill would also let Pennsylvania’s courts award damages in recognition of the companionship and affection provided by our pet dogs and cats.

 

Suits for damages would be heard at the magisterial district court level; the maximum civil penalty would be $12,000.

 

Dinniman and staff researched and drafted the bill prior to the Feb. 12 incident in West Vincent where a resident shot and killed two Bernese mountain dogs that had escaped from a neighbor’s yard and entered his property. On Feb. 22 the Chester County District Attorney charged the resident with cruelty to animals after determining “there was no justification for the killing of these two dogs.”

 

Dinniman said, “My bill, even if passed, is not retroactive and will have no direct affect on the parties in West Vincent one way or the other. But this awful shooting illustrates what can happen and the need for our justice system to better recognize the unique role pets fill in our families.”

 

“In fact, I don’t consider the civil damage award to be my bill’s main message,” Dinniman continued. “The main message is for Pennsylvania’s courts to recognize the companionship and affection provided by pets and that both have value.”

 

Under Dinniman’s bill, negligent acts could only result in a civil award if the pet at issue were on the owner’s property or under the owner’s direct control and supervision at the time of the perpetrator negligence. The bill’s language recognizes that state law requires dog-owners to keep their pets on their property or under their control.

 

The higher $12,000 amount would apply for acts that are intentional and could be awarded regardless of the harmed animal’s location, as in the case of the Bock family.

 

“We don’t want this to happen to anyone else. We want something in the books to make someone think twice before they go out and do this,” said William Bock. “And these two bills would be a significant step in the right direction.”

 

Bock and his wife, Mary Bock, met with Senator Dinniman on Tuesday to discuss needed legislative changes.

 

Tagged with:
 

Photo Gallery

Upcoming Events

November 2014
S M T W T F S
26 27 28 29 30 31 1

Category: GeneralVisit to Hope Veterinary Specialists

Close

November 1, 2014

Presenting a 10th Anniversary Citation to Hope Veterinary Specialists in Malvern.

Visit to Hope Veterinary Specialists

2 3

Category: GeneralChester County Community Foundation Legacy Awards Celebration

Close

November 3, 2014

Attending the awards celebration at West Chester University's Madeleine Wing Adler Theatre.

Chester County Community Foundation Legacy Awards Celebration

4

Category: GeneralElection Day (State Offices Closes)

Close

November 4, 2014N/A

5 6

Category: General90+ Club Visit to Brandywine Hospital Senior Circle

Close

November 6, 2014

Presenting birthday certificates to seniors who are 90 years and older as part of the 90+ Club.

90+ Club Visit to Brandywine Hospital Senior Circle

Category: GeneralHome of the Sparrow Fashion Show Event

Close

November 6, 2014

Attending Home of the Sparrow event at the Desmond in Malvern.

Home of the Sparrow Fashion Show Event

7

Category: GeneralOxford Main Street First Friday (Gone to the Dogs) Event

Close

November 7, 2014

Staff will have table.

8

Category: GeneralMount Zion AME Church's 200th Anniversary Banquet

9

Category: GeneralWest Chester Veterans Day Parade

Close

November 9, 2014

West Chester Veterans Day Parade

10 11

Category: GeneralVeterans Day (State Offices Closed)

Close

November 11, 2014N/A

12

Category: GeneralState Board of Education Meeting

Close

November 12, 2014

State Board of Education Meeting

Category: GeneralLegislative Session in Harrisburg

Close

November 12, 2014

Category: GeneralTuition Account Program (TAP) Advisory Board Meeting

Close

November 12, 2014

13

Category: GeneralState Board of Education Meeting

Close

November 13, 2014

State Board of Education Meeting

14

Category: GeneralVisit to Growing Examples in West Chester

Close

November 14, 2014

Attend Growing Examples Restorative Justice Program in West Chester.

Visit to Growing Examples in West Chester

15
16 17

Category: GeneralUniversity of Valley Forge

Close

November 17, 2014

Visit University of Valley Forge.

University of Valley Forge

18

Category: GeneralBasic Education Funding Commission Meeting

Close

November 18, 2014

19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27

Category: GeneralThanksgiving Day (State Offices Closed)

Close

November 27, 2014N/A

28

Category: GeneralState Offices Closed

Close

November 28, 2014N/A

29
30 1 2 3 4 5

Category: GeneralOxford Main Street Country Christmas

Close

December 5, 2014

Staff will have table.

Oxford Main Street Country Christmas

Category: GeneralWest Chester Old-Fashioned Christmas Parade

Close

December 5, 2014

District Office at One North Church Street will host a Holiday Open House.

West Chester Old-Fashioned Christmas Parade

6

Looking For Something

Still not finding what you're looking for? Please contact me or my staff so we can help you!